Death Cab for Cutie - We Have the Facts and We're Voting Yes
MusicMash Rating: not rated yet
Pitchfork Media Rating: 7.5
There's something about the Pacific Northwest. Perhaps it's being overshadowed by towering evergreens that
instills a modest reverence for beauty. Perhaps it's the evergreens remaining ever green under the gusts of
snow which keeps hope alive. Perhaps it's the cradling of cold coast and the Rocky wall. Whatever the causes,
the Pacific Northwest has played womb to some of the most skyward, heart-wrenching, and gentle pop music of
recent history.
The trademarks of the Northwest sound continue to be cherubic eunuchs on vocals, crisp production, slow
rollercoaster melodies, and tales of crushes and the crushed. Built to Spill, Elliott Smith, Quasi, Sunny
Day Real Estate, and even Modest Mouse and Caustic Resin, to some extent, all revolve around this central
axis of Northwestern pop. In two short albums, Death Cab for Cutie have firmly established a stylistic
nexus from which all of these bands spoke. Like history in reverse, We Have the Facts and We're Voting
Yes documents the proto-Northwest sound as a footnote to a decade of tranquilizing rock.
Death Cab for Cutie effortlessly weep gems like a band stuck deep in a comfortable career. Subcutaneous
organ and glockenspiel infuse warm, rich tones which bruise slowly between skeletal percussion and waxy
guitar pickings. Sometimes the band patiently fills wooden cathedrals with echoes of reverberating slowcore,
like on "No Joy in Mudville" and "The Employment Pages". The latter builds to an e-bow climax that weakens
like a welcome influenza. "For What Reason", "Lowell, MA", and "Company Calls" click along at quick clips,
yet maintain the shroud of delicate beauty thanks to Ben Gibbard's lachrymose wails. From a distance, the
group appears manilla. But even top secret documents come stuffed in manilla. Subtle technological flourishes
glimmer under the organic pulp like microchips in lumberjacking valleys.
If fault can be found, it's Death Cab for Cutie's continual quest to shine a diamond from...
Read the complete review here